A federal judge has barred immigration agents from making arrests at immigration courthouses nationwide, closing off one of the most productive — and most criticized — enforcement tactics of the past year.
What the Ruling Says
U.S. District Judge Casey Pitts found that ICE’s policy permitting arrests at immigration courthouses was arbitrary and capricious, and blocked the practice nationwide. An earlier case in New York had barred courthouse arrests at two specific locations; the Pitts ruling was the first to apply across the country.
Why Courthouse Arrests Were So Effective — and So Contested
Immigration courthouses are one of the few places where the government knows exactly when a noncitizen will appear. Stationing agents there converts a legal obligation to attend a hearing into an arrest opportunity.
That is precisely why critics called the practice corrosive. A court system depends on people showing up. When attending your own hearing carries a risk of detention, the rational response is to stay away — which produces in-absentia removal orders and undermines the proceedings the government says it wants people to attend.
What It Does Not Change
The ruling addresses immigration courthouses specifically. It does not restrict enforcement at other locations, and a separate ruling has allowed ICE to continue courthouse arrests in a New York City legal challenge on different grounds. The government may appeal, and the nationwide scope of injunctions has itself been a live legal issue.
More Read
What This Means If You Have a Hearing
Attend your immigration court hearings. Missing a hearing can result in an in-absentia removal order, which is far harder to undo than most people expect. If you have concerns about attending, raise them with an immigration attorney before your hearing date rather than skipping it. Keep a copy of your hearing notice and confirm your date through the EOIR automated case information system. This article is for general information only and is not legal advice.
Sources: Ruling by U.S. District Judge Casey Pitts blocking immigration courthouse arrests nationwide, reported by The Hill; related coverage of the New York courthouse arrest litigation.
Follow @DailyImmigrant for accurate, timely immigration news and updates every day.
